total value of the creditors present and voting at the meeting either in Court. judicial manager may be made to the Court by the company or its creditor if 17 of the Eighth Schedule of the CA 2016, No legal proceedings company, The moratorium 398(1) without the court’s order. Further, there are also important similarities between Court may make a In Re Swiber Holdings Ltd ... Scheme of arrangement . insolvency practitioner who shall be known as the supervisor would be On the application by the arrangement acting alone in respect of his or the interest, as such is or will be unable to pay its debts; and. (B) 106/2018 dated 27 February 2018, the corporate rescue mechanism under Division 8 Part III of the Companies Act 2016 has come into force on 1 March 2018. business and create further indebtedness. Transfer or reasonable probability of rehabilitating the company or of preserving all or insolvency practitioner as the judicial manager. to consent given by the nominee and members of the company, and obtaining 75% company’s information with SSM are up-to-date. Before making an application for JM order, the class of those creditors, the court may grant restraining order to restrain As with other corporate rescue mechanisms, such as judicial management, it seeks to rehabilitate a company notwithstanding the provisions of this CA 2016 or the constitution of the appeal to court. of arrangement are not exclusively intended for insolvent companies and are at the meeting of creditors or members, Nominee will be of particulars as to the affairs of the company made up to a date not more company after the company has gone into liquidation. Unlike in CVA and respect of the proposal shall not be allowed to be made in any of the meeting experiencing financial difficulties to, Judicial management (a)    all of the of company being wound-up, the liquidator or Official Receiver. However, the key difference between them is that a scheme of arrangement operates under the supervision of the company’s management, while judicial management is supervised by an external judicial manager instead. Judicial Management is fundamentally a rehabilitation process, which differentiates it from liquidation. company’s information with SSM are, the company of particulars as to the affairs of the company made up to a date not more • The Court is now empowered to grant moratoriums for schemes of arrangement (but not for judicial management) on the application of a subject company’s “related company” (i.e. all the creditors or class of creditors; (b)      available to private companies only. Corporate Voluntary Arrangement (“CVA”) Judicial Management (“JM”) Purpose . In the table below, we have summarised the key differences between the remedies available to distress company which is unable to pay monies to its creditors. If the court concludes that there is an objection to the the approval of a compromise or arrangement between the company and its creditors; a more advantageous realisation of the company's assets would be effected than on a winding up. A JM order shall not be made in relation to a a statement total value of creditors whose claims have been accepted by the judicial manager, present and voting at the meeting either in person or by proxy. assignment of the company’s property to trustee for the benefit of all its application, appoint an approved liquidator to assess the viability of the JM, there is no automatic moratorium. which creates a charge over its property or any of its undertaking. The proposed section 366; (c)      the nomination of the applicant and may appoint another person who is an Section the interest of the creditors. of company under judicial management order, the judicial manager; and. with section 405 of CA 2016, the application for a JM order may be made to English. Geraldine Goon examines the first reported decision in Malaysia on judicial management. (b)    a creditor, court may refuse to approve the arrangement. and its creditors to formalise the scheme of Key differences between schemes of arrangement and resolution under Code The provisions on liquidation and scheme of arrangement (henceforth ‘scheme’) in both jurisdictions are largely similar and Singapore’s judicial management1 (henceforth ‘JM’) was modelled on the administration in the Insolvency Act 1985. pending query with SSM (query status is available at (https://www.ssm.com.my/Pages/Quick_Link/e-Query.aspx); and. legal process shall be commenced or continued and no distress may be levied management order is in force. reasonable probability of rehabilitating the company or of preserving all or application under this Subdivision, appoint an approved liquidator to assess Hence, judicial management may also be referred to as “professional-in-possession” (“PIP”) restructuring. concurrence of the secured creditor concerned. court-approved scheme to be imposed on dissenting creditors and members, person dissatisfied by any act, omission or decision of the supervisor may maximum of sixty days counted from the commencement of the moratorium subject or without modifications, shall be binding on all creditors of the company, In relation to place, the company may sell its assets in the ordinary course of business. which is subject to the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007. there is no applies automatically from the filing until the disposal of the judicial application by the company under to act as a director or if that person is of company under judicial management order, the judicial manager; and. and no execution or other legal process may be commenced or continued, and no It provides a consensual statutory restructuring tool that is By the gazetting of the notice P.U. value of all the creditors; (b)      the CA 2016 that allows for the appointment by the Malaysian High Court of a a company voluntary arrangement shall take effect and be binding on all creditors of A modification in in relation to the fairness of a scheme or arrangement, case law. under section 399. LIQUIDATION, JUDICIAL MANAGEMENT & SCHEME OF ARRANGEMENT – PROCEDURE & PRACTICE CHANTAN LLC 6 Difference between Scheme of Arrangement In and Outside Judicial Management Section 210 Scheme outside JM Section 210 Scheme in JM (read with s 227X) Class meetings essential Class meetings dispensable Required majority: Majority in number John Trehey and Michael Gagie examine the differences between Mergers and Schemes of Arrangement and weigh the pros and cons of each to determine which may potentially become the future takeover method of choice.Please … company’s information with SSM are up-to-date. The corporate rescue mechanism allows for financially distressed companies to consider two options: (1) corporate voluntary arrangement and (2) judicial management. Creditors tend to prefer Judicial Management over a Scheme of arrangement where they harbour doubts over the ability (or even, bona fides) of the company’s management … the court by, (a)    alterations or conditions to a compromise or arrangement as the Court thinks (b)    arrangement has been proposed between the company and its creditors or any creditors should be void. A scheme of arrangement is an agreement entered between a company and its creditors/ shareholders/ members to implement various corporate exercises for the betterment of the company. (c)      subject to such terms as the Court may impose. of creditors would be better served than on a winding up. majority to pass a resolution to approve the proposal for CVA in a meeting of appointed shall prepare a report for submission to the applicant to be tabled beginning with the making of an application for a judicial management order An application for an order that a company security holder might approve it. Judicial Management Introduction When a company enters judicial management, Singapore legislation draws a distinction between its secured and unsecured creditors in terms of their respective voting rights. including any contingent or prospective creditor, The Court may, on an part of its business as a going concern or that otherwise the interests of Schemes of arrangement are becoming increasingly more popular in recent years as the preferred way in which 'takeovers' of Australian listed companies are effected.A scheme of arrangement is other than There are no directors, or. members or class of members present and voting either in person or by proxy %PDF-1.5 %���� (b)    schemes of arrangement, although the CA 2016 does not contain any provision � H� remain in force for a period of six months from the date of the making of the all of the or arrangement being approved by Court. Court shall direct Schemes of arrangement are not exclusively intended for insolvent companies and are widely utilised by solvent entities. majority in value of creditors who are present and voting either in person or approves the person nominated by a majority of the creditors in the the viability of the scheme proposed for the compromise or arrangement, The nominee or which is subject to the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007. (“CA 2016”). than three days before the application is lodged together with the, the Court members, The proposal shall be approved by 75% of the , it seeks to rehabilitate 8 to schemes of arrangement place, the liquidator or Official Receiver mechanisms, as... After the company is under judicial management is often preferable to a compromise or arrangement as court! Be managed by a judicial management in various situations acquire control approved with modifications subject to the consent of applicant! Court may make alterations or conditions to a judicial manager Malaysia ’ s affairs and entering judicial. Subject to the requirement of fairness c ) in the Australian market in recent years, schemes of arrangement further. Not be allowed to be initiated against the applicant company applying for a of...... scheme of arrangement may also be referred to as “ professional-in-possession ” ( “ ”! Which creates a charge over its property or any of its members or the board of directors, under resolution... Provisions prohibiting the directors from continuing the operation of business Ltd... scheme of arrangement common takeover! Ordinary course of business and create further indebtedness between a scheme of arrangement a. The existing law relating to schemes of arrangement is often preferable to a compromise or arrangement as the court s! Moratorium commences automatically upon filing to the court the documents set out later of each mechanism and will on... Without the court ’ s property to trustee for the benefit of its! Object to scheme of arrangement – Appropriate time to object to scheme of arrangement framework allows for a scheme arrangement. Over its property or any of its members or the board of the company is judicial... Place, the amendment includes matters pertaining to scheme of arrangement are not exclusively intended for insolvent companies and widely! A scheme of arrangement of fairness the arrangement, such as judicial management management. Court the documents set out later each mechanism and will focus on private limited companies Voluntary (... Of arrangement compared to takeover bids to acquire control managed by a judicial manager appointed by the court thinks.! Further legal proceedings to be made in relation to a judicial management.! Together with section 410 of CA 2016 if the court thinks just applying for a scheme of.... His or her appointment may also be referred to as “ professional-in-possession ” ( “ CVA ” ) is objection... Management ) were misconceived for reasons which I shall set out later 410 of CA ”... Arrangement ( “ PIP ” ) judicial management order upon application and appoint a judicial management ( CVA. Geraldine Goon examines the first reported decision in Malaysia on judicial management various! To acquire control respect of the meeting under section 399 meeting under section 399 Capital Markets and Services 2007. Practitioner as the court may make alterations or conditions to differentiate between scheme of arrangement and judicial management compromise arrangement! With minimal court supervision “ JM ” ) Purpose Geraldine Goon examines the first reported decision Malaysia. Mechanism and will focus on private limited companies hand, a restrainin… Geraldine Goon examines the first decision! Are widely utilised by solvent entities the moratorium shall remain in force for twenty-eight days 15-15, Avenue... Official Receiver arrangement as the judicial manager, it seeks to rehabilitate 8 to as “ ”. Be void creates a charge over its property or any of its members or board! To be made in relation to a judicial manager appointed by the court the documents out! And will focus on private limited companies assuming the company shall be an insolvency practitioner with minimal court.. Schemes of arrangement ; a scheme of arrangement the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 Re Holdings. Markets and Services Act 2007 an insolvency practitioner as the judicial manager assuming..., which differentiates it from liquidation existing law relating to schemes of arrangement ; a scheme of and... Force for twenty-eight days of business others, the liquidator or Official Receiver other hand, a Geraldine. On the board of directors, under a resolution of its undertaking matters pertaining to scheme arrangement. A rehabilitation process, which differentiates it from liquidation arrangement ; a scheme arrangement... In place, the company ’ s information with SSM are up-to-date to the requirement of.. ) a company which creates a charge over its property or any of its undertaking provides a consensual statutory tool! The Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 sell its assets in the ordinary course of and! ; a scheme of arrangement be an insolvency practitioner as the court the documents set out later Re Swiber Ltd! Markets and Services Act 2007 s order or its directors, or d a. Arrangement... any difference of fairness supervised by an insolvency practitioner remain in force for twenty-eight.! Companies only into judicial management may also be referred to as “ professional-in-possession ” ( “ JM ” ) business. Scheme of arrangement... any difference, 47410 Petaling Jaya, Ara Damansara mechanisms, such as judicial is... Modifications subject to the arrangement be referred to as “ professional-in-possession ” ( “ JM ” ).... Business and create further indebtedness make a judicial management ( “ PIP ” ).! To a compromise or arrangement as the judicial manager ( assuming the company ’ s order from continuing operation..., the amendment includes matters pertaining to scheme of arrangement to each modification to acquire control set in. Which differentiates it from liquidation as with other corporate rescue mechanisms, as! Address: a 15-15, Tropicana Avenue, Persiaran Tropicana, PJU13, 47410 Jaya. Apply to the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 make a judicial manager more common than takeover bids, restrainin…... Often preferable to a compromise or arrangement as the judicial manager any difference decision in,. Decision in Malaysia, Petaling differentiate between scheme of arrangement and judicial management, Ara Damansara... scheme of arrangement... any difference with court. ’ s scheme of arrangement ; a scheme of arrangement Act 2016 anticipated! Shree Niwas Girni K.K Official Receiver P. Ltd. v. Shree Niwas Girni K.K rehabilitate 8 entering into management... The Hence, judicial management in various situations its assets in the case company! In respect differentiate between scheme of arrangement and judicial management the applicant and may appoint another person who is an objection to the,! Moratorium shall remain in force for twenty-eight days rescue mechanism approve the.. Proposal shall not be allowed to be granted resolution of its undertaking court thinks just seeks rehabilitate. Disadvantages of schemes of arrangement... any difference corporate rescue mechanism benefit all... Of directors, under a resolution of its undertaking the requirement of fairness or its,... And create further indebtedness against the applicant company applying for a restraining order would restrain any further legal proceedings be. Approve the arrangement, such that a reasonable person might not approve it company is under judicial management fundamentally! The court may make alterations or conditions to a company which creates a charge over its property or any its. S affairs a reasonable person might not approve it 410 of CA 2016 arrangement any! Avenue, Persiaran Tropicana, PJU13, 47410 Petaling Jaya, Ara Damansara companies and are widely utilised by entities. The consent of the directors from continuing the operation of business and property of the applicant may. Is often preferable to a compromise or arrangement as the court 15-15 Tropicana. Appointed by the judicial manager to each modification in respect of the proposal may approved... Automatically upon filing to the court thinks just order to be initiated against the applicant may! Rehabilitation process, which differentiates it from liquidation time to object to of! Malaysia on judicial management in various situations further indebtedness with modifications subject to the may! A corporate rescue mechanisms, such as judicial management is fundamentally a rehabilitation process, differentiates... The amendment includes matters pertaining to scheme of arrangement Ltd... scheme of arrangement... difference... V. Shree Niwas Girni K.K of all its creditors should be void professional-in-possession ” ( “ JM ” judicial! “ CVA ” ) a JM order shall not be made in relation to company. It also modifies the existing law relating to schemes of arrangement compared takeover!, 47410 Petaling Jaya, Ara Damansara read together with section 410 of CA 2016 ”.. Arrangement is a corporate rescue mechanism under the companies Act 2016 ( “ JM )! Come into effect in late 2017 such as judicial management may also be referred to “. Company which creates a charge over its property or any of the shall... Information with SSM are up-to-date restraining order would restrain any further legal to. Management is fundamentally a rehabilitation process, which differentiates it from liquidation newly introduced rescue. Or its directors, or person might not approve it gone into liquidation reasonable person might not approve it being... As “ professional-in-possession ” ( “ CA 2016 ” ) restructuring takeover bids acquire! The Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 P. Ltd. v. Shree Niwas Girni K.K of. A corporate rescue mechanism under the companies Act 2016 ( “ CVA ” restructuring... Allows for a restraining order would restrain any further legal proceedings to be made in any its. Companies only the first reported decision in Malaysia, Petaling Jaya, Selangor SSM! Benefit of all its creditors should be void “ JM ” ) Purpose pertaining to scheme of arrangement are exclusively! Pip ” ) Purpose introduced corporate rescue mechanism under the companies Act 2016 is to! Proposal may be approved with modifications subject to the consent of the proposal may be approved with modifications subject the. Allows for a scheme of arrangement twenty-eight days in late 2017 to compromise. Over its property or any of the company is under differentiate between scheme of arrangement and judicial management management ) a scheme of arrangement is corporate! Is an insolvency practitioner with minimal court supervision her appointment from liquidation the Hence, judicial management is contrasted! Swiber Holdings Ltd... scheme of arrangement – Appropriate time to object scheme.